1 3

Vanilla Pie

$24.99

Delivery and Shipping
  • Free Shipping on Orders $99+
  • 2 Day Transit Time
  • Orders Processed Monday-Thursday. Please note that not all areas of the US enjoy reliable Saturday delivery so some orders placed on Thursdays will be shipped on the following Monday.
  • Dry Ice and Thicker Liners used for Hotter Months/Locations
  • See our Shipping Statement page for more details. We do not ship to PO Boxes; please include a physical address in your order.

Cooking and Care Instructions

Store in freezer until ready to thaw and eat. Do not refrigerate or it will dry out.

Ingredients and Nutrition Facts

An Amish Dessert Classic

Description

Like Shoofly Pie, Vanilla Pie is a unique and delicious Amish classic. Made with quality vanilla extract, this wet bottom pie with a sweet crumb topping is bound to please. Our vanilla pie is made from scratch by a local Amish baker. No preservatives, just quality, Lancaster County goodness. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of vanilla ice cream! 8 inches in diameter. 

Reviews (0)

Payment & Security

Payment methods

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

Your payment information is processed securely. We do not store credit card details nor have access to your credit card information.

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews
33%
(1)
33%
(1)
33%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Adam R
OK

This was the first time trying the vanilla pie and I am not a big fan. It was ok, but not as good as the shoo fly pie.

G
Glenda Walden
Delicious

The pie was a big hit with my Thanksgiving guest

J
John Folk
Vanilla Pie

Packed well in plastic container, very good but it doesn't keep well in the refrigerator. It becomes hard and dry; you almost have to eat it right away.

Thank you for sharing, we would recommend letting it sit out of the cold for a bit before enjoying it. We spoke with M&A Sweet Treats, the Amish Bakers who make this item, and they recommended either freezing the pie then thawing at room temperature, or leaving it out at room temperature. They further indicated that refrigerating this pie will dry it out.

M&A

Vanilla Pie

$24.99

Like Shoofly Pie, Vanilla Pie is a unique and delicious Amish classic. Made with quality vanilla extract, this wet bottom pie with a sweet crumb topping is bound to please. Our vanilla pie is made from scratch by a local Amish baker. No preservatives, just quality, Lancaster County goodness. Pairs perfectly with a scoop of vanilla ice cream! 8 inches in diameter. 

View product
Back to top