Shoofly Pie

It been so long since I had shoofly pie - a real blast of nostalgia. Not as “wet” as my mom’s pies from my childhood, but the taste was true enough to trigger many pleasant memories.

Shipped well.

Delicious and quick shipping

I grew up in PA and have had a lot of shoefly pies. I have even made them in the past. I'm used to the molasses being really gooey. This pie was 90% topping and the "gooey" part wasn't gooey at all, just a thin layer of hard syrup.

Originally from Conestoga, currently reside in Texas. A taste of home is just a click away with Stoltzfus Meats. The Shooflypie was excellent as was the Scrapple! As always, my order arrives quickly in tact and ready to eat. I couldn't wait to sample the pepper cabbage and chow chow.

Great pie, I only bought store pies when lived in the Philly area. This is so much better than store bought. I especially liked the taste of the pie, was not expecting much of a taste, but once had the first slice had no problem eating the entire pie. Of course, not all in one sitting wanted it to last a few days.